free will

free will
The problem is to reconcile our everyday consciousness of ourselves as agents, with the best view of what science tells us that we are. Determinism is one part of the problem. It may be defined as the doctrine that every event has a cause. More precisely, for any event e, there will be some antecedent state of nature, N, and a law of nature, L, such that given L, N will be followed by e . But if this is true of every event, it is true of events such as my doing something or choosing to do something. So my choosing or doing something is fixed by some antecedent state N and the laws. Since determinism is universal these in turn are fixed, and so backwards to events for which I am clearly not responsible (events before my birth, for example). So no events can be voluntary or free, where that means that they come about purely because of my willing them when I could have done otherwise. If determinism is true, then there will be antecedent states and laws already determining such events; how then can I truly be said to be their author, or be responsible for them? Reactions to this problem are commonly classified as: (i) hard determinism. This accepts the conflict and denies that you have real freedom or responsibility. (ii) Soft determinism or compatibilism. Reactions in this family assert that everything you should want from a notion of freedom is quite compatible with determinism. In particular, even if your action is caused, it can often be true of you that you could have done otherwise if you had chosen, and this may be enough to render you liable to be held responsible or to be blamed if what you did was unacceptable (the fact that previous events will have caused you to choose as you did is deemed irrelevant on this option). (iii) Libertarianism . This is the view that, while compatibilism is only an evasion, there is a more substantive, real notion of freedom that can yet be preserved in the face of determinism (or of indeterminism ). In Kant, while the empirical or phenomenal self is determined and not free, the noumenal or rational self is capable of rational, free action. But since the noumenal self exists outside the categories of space and time, this freedom seems to be of doubtful value. Other libertarian avenues include suggesting that the problem is badly framed, for instance because the definition of determinism breaks down; or postulating a special category of uncaused acts of volition; or suggesting that there are two independent but consistent ways of looking at an agent, the scientific and the humanistic, and it is only through confusing them that the problem seems urgent. None of these avenues has gained general popularity. It is an error to confuse determinism and fatalism . See also dilemma of determinism.

Philosophy dictionary. . 2011.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Free will — free will …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Free Will — • The question of free will, moral liberty, or the liberum arbitrium of the Schoolmen, ranks amongst the three or four most important philosophical problems of all time Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Free Will     Free Will …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • FREE WILL — FREE WILL, a philosophic and theological notion referring initially to the observation that man is able to choose between a number of possible courses of action, becoming, through his choice, the cause of the action which he selects. Among… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Free-Will — Fundación 1986 Fundador(es) Hiroshi Tomioka Distribuidor En Japón: Avex Group, Sony Music Entertainment Japan, King Records, Tokuma Japan Communications y Pony Canyon. En Europa: Gan Shin, CLJ Records y Universal Music Group …   Wikipedia Español

  • Free-Will — est un important label indépendant de musique japonais, créé en 1986 par Hiroshi Dynamite Tommy Tomioka pour son groupe de rock COLOR, spécialisé depuis les années 1990 dans les groupes de rock de style visual kei , avec une branche américaine,… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Free-Will — Тип акционерное общество Год основания 1986 Расположение …   Википедия

  • Free will — 1. A will free from improper coercion or restraint. [1913 Webster] To come thus was I not constrained, but did On my free will. Shak. [1913 Webster] 2. The power asserted of moral beings of willing or choosing without the restraints of physical… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • free-will — free will, freewill free will , a. Of or pertaining to free will; voluntary; spontaneous; as, a freewill offering. [1913 Webster] {Freewill Baptists}. See under {Baptist}. [1913 Webster] …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • free|will — free will, will free from outside restraints; voluntary choice; freedom of decision. free|will «FREE WIHL», adjective. made or done freely or of one s own accord; voluntary: »a freewill offering to the Red Cross …   Useful english dictionary

  • free will — n [U] 1.) do sth of your own free will to do something because you want to, not because someone else has forced you to ▪ He came of his own free will. 2.) the ability to make your own decisions about what to do, rather than being controlled by… …   Dictionary of contemporary English

  • free|will|er — «FREE WIHL uhr», noun. a person who believes in the doctrine of free will …   Useful english dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.