# Bayle's trilemma

- In his famous article on Zeno of Elea in his
*Dictionnaire historique et critique*, Bayle represents a latter-day Zeno arguing against motion by arguing against the existence of spatial extension. There are three possible theories of spatial extension: (i) space is made of mathematical points, (ii) space is ‘granular’, made of finite atoms, (iii) space is made of parts that are divisible*in infinitum*. These three exhaust the possible theories, but none of them is tenable. The first demands that a quantity of things with no extension eventually makes up an extension, which is absurd. The second forbids us from recognizing the atoms as having parts, such as left-hand and right-hand edges, but this we must do. The third, Aristotelian, theory improperly shelters behind the notion of a purely potential infinity, forgetting that spatial (and temporal) extension is actual; it also forgets that space is continuous, i.e. its parts touch each other, whereas between any two elements of an infinite series of the kind proposed there is an infinite number of other elements. No two elements touch, any more than any two fractions are ‘next to’ one another. A modern mathematical treatment of the paradoxes (e.g. Adolf Grünbaum,*Philosophical Problems of Space and Time*, 1963) may be used to show how the first option is tenable since, as it is defined set-theoretically, the sum of any finite or infinite number of dimensionless points need not necessarily be zero. We can assign zero length to unit point sets, and differing finite lengths to the unions or sums of those sets that make up a finite interval. However, the solution requires that we are happy co-ordinating the fundamental points of space with the point sets of the theory, and the way in which space becomes describable in these terms, or in other words the ontological problem that Bayle (or Zeno) is posing, may be felt not to have been addressed. Kant makes the divisibility of space the subject of the second antinomy, and a crucial part of his idealist argument that it is we who organize experience spatially, rather than the world which is constituted of a spatial manifold. See also Zeno's paradoxes.

*Philosophy dictionary.
Academic.
2011.*

### Look at other dictionaries:

**Bayle, Pierre**— (1647–1706) French philosopher and sceptic. Born of Protestant parents in the south west of France, Bayle was educated at Toulouse, became Catholic, lapsed, fled to Geneva, and then became professor in the Protestant academy at Sedan in northern… … Philosophy dictionary**dilemma**— The simplest form of a dilemma is an argument of the form: ‘If p then q, if not p then q, so in any event q .’ More complex forms were traditionally distinguished. A constructive dilemma is of the form: ‘If p then r, if q then r, but either p or… … Philosophy dictionary**infinite divisibility**— See Bayle s trilemma, infinity, Zeno s paradoxes … Philosophy dictionary**infinity**— The unlimited; that which goes beyond any fixed bound. Exploration of this notion goes back at least to Zeno of Elea, and extensive mathematical treatment began with Eudoxus of Cnidus (4th c. BC). The mathematical notion was further developed by… … Philosophy dictionary**Vaisheshika**— (Skt., visesa, difference) One of the six orthodox schools of Indian philosophy. Vaisheshika is concerned with the things that there are, or the categories of being. Vaisheshika is a kind of atomism, holding that the basis of physical reality is… … Philosophy dictionary**Zeno's paradoxes**— Zeno of Elea s arguments against motion precipitated a crisis in Greek thought. They are presented as four arguments in the form of paradoxes : (1) the Racecourse, or dichotomy paradox, (2) Achilles and the Tortoise, (3) the Arrow, and (4) the… … Philosophy dictionary**Liste der Philosophen**— … Deutsch Wikipedia**Zeittafel zur Philosophiegeschichte**— Die nachstehende Zeittafel zur Philosophiegeschichte ist eine zeitlich geordnete Liste ausgewählter Philosophen. Sie ermöglicht eine Schnellorientierung zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Zur Einführung in philosophisches Denken ist die Zeittafel… … Deutsch Wikipedia**Problem of evil**— Part of a series on God General conceptions … Wikipedia**Deism**— For other uses, see Deism (disambiguation). Part of a series on God General c … Wikipedia